Our Score: 89.70


And now, an introduction from Pledgemaster Franco: "I've always loved getting off straight guys and catching it all on video. I'm not a cinematographer by any means, but I know how to point my camera at a naked straight guy and film him jacking off - or more! I also seem to have a knack for talking guys into getting naked for my camera. All my stuff is amateur and REAL! At Straight Fraternity, you will find 100% straight guys. My buddies and I meet most of them at gyms or straight clubs, at the beach or even right off the street. This means you'll see anyone from college types, military guys, boys next door, roughnecks, ripped gym bodies and everything in between. This is not scripted. They have no idea what's going to happen, and neither do we. What you see is real-life, first-time encounters with guys who have not been on camera before. Now come on in and see the guys in my OWN fraternity. I decide who gets in - and gets off! I'm the Pledgemaster of StraightFraternity.com!"

Full Review

Straight Fraternity is quintessential Gay Reality Sex. Few sites define the genre as well as this one. Straight Fraternity (SF) has been firing off straight boy loads online since 2007. Although having expanding upon it's initial concept, the site has consistently maintained it's 'fraternity'-like theme. No, it's not a REAL fraternity nor is it pretending to be. Instead, you have director (and glory-hole attendant) Franco heading the fraternal order of his hand-picked gay-4-pay str8 guys. Frat-daddy Franco initiates these straight guys into his funhouse of gay sex frat-pranks and invites them to take advange of his glory hole gobbling skills whenever they have the need.

The site is playful with it's gay sex activities occasionally bordering on the intense and hardcore. Common activities at the site are side by side jerk-off races, frat-paddling/spanking, gay sex dares, blow-job swapping, and the occasionally, awkward str8boy ass fucking. There's a glory-hole series of videos which is frequently updated. Solo masturbation 'audition' videos are also a staple offered at the site.

Straight Frat's str8 guy / gay-4-pay genre might be 'typical' if it weren't for the incredibly authentic array of straight guys they get to perform on camera. Some of these guys are just so awkward and hokey that they can't POSSIBLY be acting. Many claim the event at hand to be their first-time at gay sex. The scenes may not be scripted, but the straight guys aren't being hoodwinked. These straight guys know exactly what they're there to do - they just don't know how it's going to 'go down'. Even so, sometimes a few will just seem so ... well.. I want to say dim-witted but I think 'simple and honest' are more appropriate (and polite) descriptors. Franco apparently has a thing for the 'trashy white boy' type.

Occasionally Straight Frat will showcase an Ivy-League or boy-next-door type but more typically the guys seem like dropouts, ex cons, or young, aimless drifters primed for military recruitment. Models physiques range from skinny twinks to average muscle-guys and the ages of the models range from 18/19 to 30-something. The exception to this age range is the Pledgemaster himself. Something of a 'DaddyBear' - tattooed, pierced, bearded and mature Franco hosts and directs the guys who perform at Straight Frat. Franco occasionally performs as well, giving head in the Glory-hole videos. He usually appears mostly clothed (much to the disappointment of DaddyBear lovers everywhere), occasionally performing shirtless.

The camera work is definitely simple yet provides a fine 'professional amateur' experience. The video is filmed with 2 or 3 cameras on tripods, which go handheld as the action dictates. The video may not be in High Definition but the image is plenty crisp & clean and the studio well lit.

Straight Fraternity has a generous updating schedule, providing two updates a week. New, exclusive 'duo' scenes are religiously delivered every Saturday with new, exclusive bonus scenes (glory hole or audition videos mostly) released every Wednesday. With two original updates a week, the site is an amazing value at $19.95 if you sign up for a rebilling subscription (which may be canceled at anytime). There are few sites which produce as much content at such an affordable price. Single month memberships are available for a one-time charge of $24.95 if you do not trust your own ability to manage rebilling subscriptions.


As far as pro-am content goes Straight Fraternity is a gem in the crown of the Gay-4-Pay genre. It definitely ranks in the top 5 due to it's faithfulness to the genre, believability in the performances, and it's generous update schedule with it's affordable price being the irresistible "cherry on top".

Visit Straight Fraternity
Latest Videos:

JW Player Jake & The Gloryhole::115697

JW Player Real Brothers Play::115696

JW Player Chris & Gloryhole::115629

JW Player Back For More::115578

JW Player Marcus' Gay Hazing::115521

Visit Straight Fraternity

Straight Fraternity Videos & Photo Galleries

Jake & The Gloryhole

Real Brothers Play

Chris & Gloryhole

Back For More

Marcus' Gay Hazing

Gay Chicken

Junior's First Fuck

Abel & Angel Gay4Pay

Gay4Pay Army Guy

Army Man & His Buddy

Surfer Sucks Trevor

Jacob's First Fuck

Ace In The Face

Uncut Straight Guy

20 Year Old Big Dick

Spin 2: Gay Games

Light Massage

Respect & Obey

20-Year-Old Barebacks

Married Man Sucks Uncut

Robbie Gets Initiated

Choke & Paddle

Parker 2

Tricked Into Gay BJ

Hazed, Jerked & Blown

Go Gay For Pay

Bareback Virgin

First Gay Blowjob

Double Gloryhole

Blaine & Blue

Gay Chicken Part 2

Gay Chicken Part 1

Army Stud Gets Blown

Luke Gets Fucked Bareback

Irish-American Soldier

Navy Buddies Play Gay ...

Garrett's 5-Way

Military Guy BJ & Fing...

Uncut Nikko Jacks Off

Married Guy Alec Gets ...

CT Jacks Off A Black Guy

Hung College Guy's Glo...

Nito & BJ First Time

Dax and BJ Go Gay 4 Pay

Marky's Ass Play

Grant Barebacks

He's So Gay

Dax's 5-Way with the B...

Axel and Brian Bareback

Ty Tucker Bound & Blin...

Victor's Audition

Scrappy Milked

Nito Hazed

Dee Fucks Franco Bareback

Real Frat Brother's 1s...

Cody Makes Angel Go Ga...

Naked Truth Or Dare 3-Way

Jordan's Audition

CJ and Trey Fuck

Van's First Gay Blowjob

Trevor's First Gay Fuck

Bronson's Audition

Straight Buddies TJ an...

Muscular Young Leon At...

Fucking Hard

Joseph's Audition

Trevor's Big Dick Sucked

Ty Tucker Fucks Robbie

Damian's Audition

Straight Roughneck Joe...

Alex Sucking Huge Cock

Married Med Student Vl...

Leon's First Anal Plea...

Link's 1st Gay BJ and ...

Cameron's Audition

Married Straight Guy S...

David's Audition

Jason and Milo


Handsome Latino Nito J...

Hung Black and White G...

Uncut Latino Military ...

Chicken 2: Kai and Bos...

Cisco's First Time Fuc...

Straight Firefighter B...

Gay Chicken: Best Frie...

Hung Black Athlete At ...


Blake Barnes' Audition

19 y.o. Trevor's Huge ...

Tony Dinero's Big Dick...

Laurent Blown

Jace: Navy Guy's Surpr...

Beefy Bald Guy Blown

DJ: Ex-Con Hungry For ...

Bailey: Construction W...

James: Straight, Engag...

Ace's Enormous Black D...

Makai Shoots A Big Load

Orion's First Asshole ...